Arresting Hope reminds us that prisons are not only places of punishment, marginalization, and trauma, but that they can also be places of hope, blessing even, where people with difficult lived experiences can begin to compose stories full of healing, anticipation, communication, education, connection, and community. The book tells a story about women in a provincial prison in Canada, about how creative leadership fostered opportunities for transformation and hope, and about how engaging in research and writing contributed to healing.
The book includes poetry, stories, letters, interviews, fragments of conversations, reflections, memories, quotations, journal entries, creative nonfiction, and scholarly research. Out of multiple and diverse possibilities involving many people, Arresting Hope is focused on five women—a prison doctor, a prison warden, a prison recreation therapist, a prison educator, and a prison inmate—and their stories of grief, desire, and hope.
Ruth Elwood Martin: I worked as family physician in Vancouver from 1983 to 2009; I also worked part-time in the medical clinics of bc correctional centres for men and women for seventeen years. I am a Clinical Professor of the School of Population and Public Health, University British Columbia, and an Associate Faculty of the Department of Family Practice. My experiences as a prison physician participatory researcher during the time period of Arresting Hope changed me, such that my goal became to foster the improvement of prison health and to engage patients’ voices in the process. I helped create the Collaborating Centre for Prison Health and Education, which is a group committed to encouraging and facilitating collaborative opportunities for health, education, research, service and advocacy, to enhance the social well-being and (re)integration of individuals in custody, their families and communities. I also lead the Prison Health Special Interest Focused Practice Group, of the College of Family Physicians of Canada.
Mo Korchinski: Since writing Arresting Hope, I have found my three children through Facebook and have a loving relationship with my children today. I am a proud grandmother to a beautiful four-year-old granddaughter, Letisha, who has taught me what unconditional love is. I live independently and am graduated in May 2012 from the Nicola Valley Institute of Technology with my degree in Associate of Arts. I started my Bachelor in Social Work in September 2012. I volunteer as a community-based researcher with Women in2 Healing and work as a research assistant with the Canadian Institute of Health Research funded project “Doing Time Unlocking the Gates” at the University of British Columbia. I am clean and sober and spend most of my spare time helping others in my community. I feel that the key to turning one’s life around and keeping it moving in the right direction is to help others turn their lives around. I co-directed the documentaries Revolving Door and Unlocking the Gates, which are about women’s release from prison, and when the prison gate is unlocked, but the doors to society are kept locked. My passion is to take my experience of addiction and the justice system and show people that changes are needed: to get the voices of women who are still inside of prison heard; and, to get policy-makers to understand that change is needed in the prison system and in the communities.
Lynn Fels: Working on this book project and with those involved in the research project in accw has been an unexpected gift for me. I am humbled and awed by the strength, wisdom, and commitment that the women I have met bring to our conversations and shared experiences. I came to understand that the stories we live, dwell in our bodies. We are marked by our beginnings and by those we meet on our life journey, but we may take action to change our narrative. I am a writer and Associate Professor in Arts Education at Simon Fraser University in British Columbia, and a former editor of the on-line education journal, Educational Insights. I am passionate about the arts as exploratory spaces for learning. I am currently involved in a five-year research project on arts for social change in Canada. My books include, Living Together: Unmarried Couples in Canada, and, co-authored with George Belliveau, Exploring Curriculum: Performative Inquiry, Role Drama and Learning.
Carl Leggo: I am a poet and professor in the Department of Language and Literacy Education at the University of British Columbia. I think we can live more joyful lives if we commit ourselves to writing about our lived experiences and sharing our stories, poetry, and wisdom with others. So, it is a joy to work with others to encourage them to write and to reveal their voices with heart and truthfulness. I have published several books of poetry and scholarship, always with a focus on creativity and the arts, including: Growing Up Perpendicular on the Side of a Hill; View from My Mother’s House; Come-By-Chance; Teaching to Wonder: Responding to Poetry in the Secondary Classroom; Lifewriting as Literary Métissage and an Ethos for Our Times (co-authored with Erika Hasebe-Ludt and Cynthia Chambers); Being with A/r/tography (co-edited with Stephanie Springgay, Rita L. Irwin, and Peter Gouzouasis); Creative Expression, Creative Education (co-edited with Robert Kelly); and Poetic Inquiry: Vibrant Voices in the Social Sciences (co-edited with Monica Prendergast and Pauline Sameshima).
Contributing Author Bios:
Alison Granger-Brown: I was sent quite by accident to the Forensic Psychiatric Hospital for my first practicum in Therapeutic Recreation (tr). Once there I realized that something about the setting was compelling and that I wanted to work in a related field. I completed my preceptorship at Burnaby Correctional Centre for Women and have continued working with incarcerated women ever since. Thirteen years later, I have worked in both provincial and federal custody from segregation to open custody and also with women on parole. The most exciting and fulfilling time of my career was at accw. It was an opportunity to start something new as we set a very clear intention from the beginning working together with the women and staff to create a special environment open to creative programming and most especially supporting hope and possibility for us all. I have used my previous education in nursing along with tr and developed my recent academic studies around the learning needs of women in a prison setting. I recently completed my Ph.D. but nothing will equate to what I have learned from the women I have been privileged to journey alongside for the last dozen or so years.
Amber Christie: I am a Cree First Nations woman. I was first incarcerated in 2000 at the age of twenty, and I returned to prison thirty times over the next five years. In my most recent incarceration in 2005, I spent six months inside Alouette Correctional Centre for Women. Before that, I had spent time in Surrey Pretrial and Burnaby Correctional Centre for women. I suffered from a severe heroin addiction for many years and lived on the streets. Today, I have been free of drugs and prisons for five years. I am a mother and a contributing member of society. I am a Research Assistant for the University of British Columbia, working in community-based participatory research. I am employed by the project called “Doing Time,” and I am part of the “Women in2 Healing“ team. I also work with a community-based participatory research project called “Aboriginal Healing Outside of the Gates.” My goal is to support women in the reintegration process so that they can safely reintegrate into their chosen communities.
Brenda Tole: I retired after a thirty-seven-year career with bc Corrections Branch. I graduated with a Bachelor in Education from the University of British Columbia and started my career as a community Probation Officer/Family Court Counsellor. I worked in various communities in the Lower Mainland over the next fifteen years, followed with a variety of management positions in different correctional centres in the custody division. The last position I held was as the Warden of Alouette Correctional Centre for Women from 2003-2007. I live with my husband Mark and spend time with five grown children and six grandchildren between Cultus Lake and Galiano Island.
Christine Hemingway : While incarcerated at ACCW, I was one of many women to start the participatory research program with Dr Ruth Martin. We discovered and learned many things that were needed for women while incarcerated and help for when women are released. I have remained in touch with Women in2 Healing and have helped by telling my story to give women hope that when they are released they are not alone. Since my release in November 2006, I have been very active in trying to help change health care inside the prisons for women. I was also a member of the University of British Columbia roundtable international conference Bonding Through Bars, with many delegates from around the world, to keep mothers and their babies together while incarcerated. My son, who is now twenty years old and an airline pilot, also helped with the roundtable project, voicing his thoughts on how he was affected at the age of eleven years being separated from me for seventeen months. I now own a store and work very hard at communicating with my son, which we didn’t do until we both got involved with Bonding Through Bars; it really helped us to open up. My son and I will continue to help mothers connect with their children upon release. I am very grateful that I became involved with the research team and Women in2 healing; it has helped me get my life back and become a productive member of society.
Debra Hanson: I was a passionate member of the accw inmate participatory research team. A former restaurant manager, I brought team organizational expertise to the participatory research project. I have two grown daughters who had been in and out of the correctional system and I truly wanted to get involved in helping to build the strengths of the women in the research team. I led the development of an orientation package for all new team members, and the ‘paragraphs of passion’ exercise, which women participated in when they joined the research team. I taught myself PowerPoint and other computer skills, and then coached other team members in these skills. My research passion was housing, because I knew that housing is the first step to improving women’s health when they leave prison. I am currently working as a baker.
Teagen: I have a busy and great life. My son started kindergarten in September 2011 and I’m having a blast helping him with all his school activities. When I’m not with him, I am in class at Douglas College where I am two years into my psychiatric nursing degree. When not at school or with my son, I can be found at the care facility I have been working at since 2008. In our downtime, we love to play outside or visit with our family.
Jen Flavel: Jen was a much loved daughter, mother, and friend to many. She had a passion for photography and took a ton of pictures. Jen’s life ended tragically and too early.
Kelly Murphy: While incarcerated in 2005, I participated in the Women In2 Healing research project, which seeks to collaborate with women as they are being released into the community and to improve their health during that process. I have arisen out of abuse and adversity and I am now passionately involved in helping other women find their voice and rise out of oppressive circumstances. Working with narratives and dialogue, I advocate to tell the stories of the women that I journey with. I live in Vancouver and have been employed with ubc since 2008, working on various community based research projects. I am one of the founding members of Women in2 Healing working in the community to assist women offenders to end the stigmatization of incarcerated women.
Lara-Lisa Condello: I am an Instructor and the Justice Studies Department Head at Nicola Valley Institute of Technology (nvit)—bc’s Aboriginal post-secondary institute. I founded nvit’s prison education program. I participate on prison program advisory committees and am a co-investigator on a participatory action research team at ubc. Advocating prison human rights, I am concerned with issues such as health. A practitioner of Indigenous collaborative learning, I apply artistic media to address the provocative yet often misunderstood concepts of penal abolition and transformative justice. I am passionate about progressive social change and am committed to promoting life-long learning and grassroots community development.
Linnea Groom : As a mother of two adult sons, wife, and sister of two brothers, I felt challenged at the thought of relating exclusively to females, when asked to coordinate the w2 volunteer program in a women’s institution. My two-decade involvement with people in incarceration began on a volunteer basis, along with my husband. My passion for relating to people who are marginalized in this way came from my lived experience of being a visual racial minority in the community where I spent much of my childhood. I find joy in affirming women in their value and abilities.
Lisa Torikka: I have been a resident at the Gateway of Hope as part of the Opportunities Program since my release from accw. Since that time, I have worked hard. I completed (with honours) a twenty-week Cooks Training Program, I have become a first year apprentice with ita as a cook, I work part-time jobs, and have full-time employment starting in September with Kwantlen University, and achieved many smaller goals such as getting id, learning how to budget, obtaining a driver’s license etc. I now know how valuable supported living is. I always thought, in the past, that I could do it on my own, I know differently now. This has been one of the biggest changes I made in my life, to let others help me, to humble myself, and allow people to guide me. I have many more goals to accomplish and believe that one of them is helping women that come out of prison. I don’t really know what that looks like yet, but I do know that by just doing what I am doing, by living my life the way it was meant to be lived is helping to inspire other women to try and do the same, and for now, that is enough.
Marie Fayant (Holy Cow): I am a Cree descendent from Saskatoon Saskatchewan. I have two beautiful sons, six grandchildren, and one great-grandchild born. I have worked with our Métis Society in Surrey, the community with Kla-how-eya with the children and families, I worked for a short time as a Counsellor at Native Education Centre, and I take part in Ceremonies whenever requested at Langara College and Simon Fraser University. I am involved with the First Nations Breast Cancer Society as a Director. I started to work in the women’s correctional centre when two wonderful co-workers, and one woman in prison who had cancer, convinced me that they needed an Elder/Spiritual Advisor. I have worked in provincial and federal centres and volunteered for many years in the male correctional institutions. I invite inmates to come to sweats in the community with their families when they are released from prison.
Marnie Scow: I am twenty-four years old, and I have been out of prison and living clean off drugs and alcohol for almost three years. I attend Douglas College; I am completing my ba in Criminology, with a minor in Psychology, before attending law school at University of British Columbia. I hope to become a criminal defense attorney. I am actively involved in both my community and school as well as with Women in2 Healing. I have shared my story and my experience, strength, and hope with several organizations across the province in hopes of helping others realize that there is another way to live. I am also employed fulltime as an assistant manager in a Greek tavern.
Melissa Glover: Melissa was a strong woman with a beautiful smile who was passionate about life. Melissa loved making everyone laugh with “tearful, non-stop giggles.” Melissa’s poetry reflects much of her journey through life: “the good, bad and the ugly.” Melissa was an enthusiastic member of the participatory research team, and her passion was to become healthy so that she could spend more time with her daughter. Melissa’s life ended tragically and too early. She is missed by many.
Rene Chan: I am a gentle and loving woman and help others whenever I can. I trained as an inmate peer educator and believe that education is a way for incarcerated women to improve their lives and their own health. I have been through hell and back, only making me more compassionate and less judgemental. Although we hear “no you can’t, you’ll never make it…” we have proven that we can! Everybody’s dreams are possible and I am living well into my dreams today.
Annette Dubrule: After I was released from prison, I worked for two years as a research assistant on the Doing Time participatory research project in Prince George, bc, and then I worked as a receptionist for a law firm for eighteen months. I am hoping to take the Medical Laboratory Assistant program online through Thompson Rivers University, and have arranged a practicum for this in Quesnel, bc. I spend as much time as I can with my son, who stays with me every alternate week, and I communicate daily with my daughter who lives in Ontario with her father. I stay in shape, when not working or taking courses, by attending the gym regularly, climbing Cut Banks, and going for long walks and hikes. I have always had an interest for photography and I enjoy taking and then modifying pictures. I still live with my mom out in Blackburn, where we own a log home that requires much maintenance, which I enjoy doing. I recently applied for a pardon.
Terry Howard: I began prison outreach as a volunteer twelve years ago and jumped at the opportunity to coordinate the prison outreach program for the Positive Living Society of bc. I started working with the women at Alouette Correctional Centre for Women in 2005 and was immediately captivated by the organic information dissemination among the women who were part of the community-based research project Women in2 Healing. I was stunned at the new passion to pass on the information from their presentations to the other women incarcerated with them in an informal, yet incredibly effective educational blitz. In my years of prison outreach, I had never seen an uptake of information as effective as what happened among the women with their newfound knowledge of the power of education. They were passionate, informed and intent on letting other women know of the dangers inherent in their own issue. This experience forever transformed my approach to working with people in prison. I am now the Director of Community-Based Research for Positive Living bc (formerly bc Persons With aids Society).
Vivian Ramsden: I am a Registered Nurse and received a Ph.D. in Interdisciplinary Studies from the University of Saskatchewan. I am a Professor and Director of the Research Division, Department of Academic Family Medicine at the University of Saskatchewan. My background spans both critical care in acute care settings and primary health care in urban, rural, First Nations, and international communities. My research interests are: primary health care, participatory processes of research and evaluation; mixed methods; and, prevention of chronic diseases. I spend a portion of each year working at Omayal Achi College of Nursing in Chennai, India.
Tanya Newell: I had been in and out of jail since I was a juvenile in 2005. When I had Mason at the age of thirty, I had already served over ten years in institutions: I was institutionalized and I was completely oblivious to the fact that things needed to change. My plan on my release day was always to get high, to return to place of my offence and arrest (where my “friends” were) and to continue the cycle of addiction and crime that I knew. The chance to bring my baby back to the prison after his birth changed my life for the better. Having Mason with me at accw allowed for bonding that we otherwise wouldn’t have had an opportunity to have. Had I not been allowed to go to the prison with my infant son, the bonding would not have been there: my plans would have completely changed for release and I would probably still be in the (correctional) system today. Having Mason with me in prison, made me be more accountable in my release planning and I had to orchestrate a plan that was suitable for both him and I. It made me really have to look at the options, read the literature and look into what these houses had to offer—I was responsible for another life. From accw, we went to Peardonville Treatment facility, because they accept babies there at three months old. I have been out of jail since then, with the exception of one return for charges that I’d already had prior to Mason’s birth. I am drug and alcohol free. I am happy and healthy. I have my children in my life: Mitch, Mason, and now Tyson. Mason is a wonderful little boy; he is caring and kind, good-natured and well behaved: a happy normal little boy that was not negatively affected by the circumstance.
Arresting Hope: Women Taking Action in Prison Health Inside Out
Edited by R. Elwood Martin, M. Korchinski, L. Fels and C. Leggo
reviewed by Martin Dufresne
Herizons – Summer 2015
Any narrative about the prison system that gets a glowing review from the Elizabeth Fry Society's Kim Pate is bound to speak to the hearts of feminists concerned with systemic racism and sexism.
Arresting Hope is also commended as “inspirational” by former Supreme Court Justice Ian Bennie. He particularly latched on, as did I, to Mo Korchinski's poetic impressions, which are presented among the “paragraphs of passion" penned by incarcerated women. Overall, this is a gripping account of how the staff and detainees of the B.C. Alouette Correctional Centre for Women (ACCW) rose collectively to a relative empowerment when our society gave them half a chance 10 years ago.
First-person reports of social experiments usually end up on some dusty shelf or, these days, in a Harper shredder. Arresting Hope proves a much better read, maybe because it combines various perspectives: those of women inmates, including stark, poignant narrative of “life before jail,” a recreational therapist, a prison doctor and a visionary warden. Bucking tradition, all managed to transform the ACCW environment by reimagining their lives with the help of an elder who made Alouette into a place of hope.
Those participants testify about processing their situations through creativity sessions that included autonomous gardening, nature outings, access to a sweat lodge and addressing the outside community, as well as by being allowed to maintain contact with their babies.
This common sense reform —Canada being one of the laggards in that regard —was gutted by new ACCW administrators in 2008 but reinstated by the 13.C. Supreme Court last December. Indeed, the reader is left wanting to know more about why authorities shut down the Alouette program.
“Arresting Hope provides a window into what is possible when committed, passionate women are supported to do what is right and refuse to accept the bounds of institutional and bureaucratic restrictions. Women whose lives represented a litany of abuse and oppression were provided with opportunities to heal, learn and grow. In this book, we meet some of the women who participated and are among the finest, most compassionate and accomplished advocates with whom I have had the pleasure to collaborate. Sadly, this is far too unique and the reality remains that the success of this initiative in challenging prison systems, structures and authorities was what led to the undermining and vilification of the administration who supported it. This is a must read for those who want to try to inspire renewed hope and pry open storm shutters that currently board up this window.“
- Kim Pate, Executive Director, Canadian Association of Elizabeth Fry Societies
“I found Arresting Hope deeply moving. What made me cry were the stories of redemption: where some of the women come out of prison with some support and made better lives for themselves and others. The sense for me in reading Arresting Hope is that a few people came into some of those women’s lives and gave them a pleasant environment — “stepping out of the van and into natural beauty”— and worked with them, whatever the cost, human endeavour, resulting in redeeming some lives that have gone bad. A note that struck me was the integrity of the people involved in the process. Also, the women were sent out of prison with an affirmation, “you have courage in you, you have honesty in you.” We all need this kind of blessing, but for people to give this blessing to women who have never heard these words before, is very moving. When I now hear the news (about being hard on crime), I feel differently; there’s an awareness in me now. Arresting Hope made me want to go and volunteer in a prison. It opened up opportunities. It’s a must read for anyone who has a sense of social conscience and humanity. It is about how we treat each other.”
- Lindi Lewis, Language Teacher, Vancouver, Canada
“Arresting Hope is an impressive and valuable book giving insight in the minds and experiences of detained women, like never done before. The conversations, letters and stories are touching and make the reader realize how important positivism, safety and hope are within the prison setting. It demonstrates that small changes in environment and attitudes as well as a gender-sensitive approach make a big difference for detained women, making use of the unique opportunity for reflection, learning and health. A woman’s fundamental right to health is addressed not only by access to health services but also by addressing several factors improving her mental and physical health and well-being. Arresting Hope shows that if prisons are made into constructive settings, much can be achieved in the time period women are imprisoned.”
- Brenda van den Bergh, World Health Organization, Regional Office for Europe
“I found Arresting Hope to be an inspirational story told by very credible people— a wonderful collection of poems and essays and "paragraphs of passion". I thought everything about Mo Korchinski was great, from her entry ("locked away from everyone like a child no one wants") to her departure ("as I walked through the gate three bald eagles flew above me -- the grandfathers watching over me") and everything in between ( "in prison goof is a term reserved for child molesters") . The prison programs allowing child rearing and the "research" projects seem such sensible ideas; one wonders why it took such unusual staff to get them up and running."
- Ian Binnie, retired Justice of the Supreme Court of Canada
An Invitation to Readers
Babies in Prison
Participatory Health Research
Stories of Transformation
An Invitation to Readers
This book tells a story about women in a provincial prison in Canada, about how creative leadership fostered opportunities for transformation and hope, and about how engaging in research and writing contributed to healing. The book involves many people, but it is focused on five remarkable women: a doctor, a warden, a recreation therapist, an educator, and an inmate. Christina Baldwin claimed that “story heals” (42). As a collective of four co-editors, we all share the conviction that we need to tell more stories. We agree with Baldwin that “when we live in a family, a community, a country where we know each other’s true stories, we remember our capacity to lean in and love each other into wholeness” (18). In order to learn to live together in the ways of connection, hope, and generosity, we must narrate our lives, and we must hear the stories of others. Together, we break silences, tell the truths of our lives, and learn how to listen to the stories of others as a commitment to living with healing and wellness.
While stories are personal, individual, and subjective, the personal is also universal. Our personal stories are connected to history. We are all inextricably and integrally connected as human beings. So, when we tell our stories to others, and when we listen to others tell us their stories, we discover that we are all searching for belonging, for home, for community. Parker Palmer claimed that while our culture “separates inner from outer, private from public, personal from professional” (47), “we all live on the Möbius strip” where “there is no ‘inside’ and ‘outside’” (47). According to Palmer, “we are continually engaged in the evolution of self and world—and we have the power to choose, moment by moment, between that which gives life and that which deals death” (48).
Arresting Hope is a unique book for many reasons, but especially because of the way in which the story of the prison is narrated. In social science research, narrative inquiry typically involves three principal dynamics: story, interpretation, and discourse. Story is what happened. Therefore, story can be researched by asking the journalist’s questions: who? what? when? where? why? how? Interpretation addresses the basic question of so what? In other words, what is the significance of the story? In much social science research, the question of interpretation is often cast as the most important question because so much social science research is about conclusions and implications. The social scientist always asks: What does all this mean for practice and policy? But instead of emphasizing story or interpretation, we emphasize the third dynamic of narrative inquiry. Discourse is about how we tell the story. Discourse refers to the rhetoric of storytelling, the art and science of shaping and constructing a story for communicating to others (Leggo; Chatman).
The purpose of telling our stories is to tell them in ways that open up new possibilities for understanding, wisdom, and transformation. So, our stories need to be told in ways that arrest attention, that call out, that startle, so that we attend to our stories and the stories of others with renewed focus. It is not enough to just tell our stories. We need to learn to tell them in creative ways. This is the heart of story-making and narrative inquiry.
Arresting Hope includes poetry, stories, letters, interviews, fragments of conversations, reflections, memories, quotations, journal entries, creative nonfiction, and scholarly research. Telling the whole story of the Alouette Correctional Centre for Women is an impossibility, simply because there are so many stories lived by so many people. Out of the multiple and diverse possibilities, we are narrating the stories of a group of women who gathered to teach one another, and to share their stories of grief, desire, and hope.
Arresting Hope narrates a complex story with many lines of connection, and it narrates this complex story in a diverse range of texts like fragments of an immense story. Jean Baudrillard noted that “fragmentary writing is, ultimately, democratic writing. Each fragment enjoys an equal distinction” (8). But we also contend that fragmentary writing invites dialogue and imaginative engagement by readers. Instead of attempting to tell the whole story or even a seamless story with a clear and coherent chronology, we invite readers to linger with the fragments, to attend to the composition of the fragments as artistic renderings that evoke and provoke. Arresting Hope does not present a linear and straightforward narrative. Instead, it narrates the tangled chaos of lived experience by presenting a complex network of images and stories that evoke an understanding of people and their hopes and desires. By attending to the story as “an archipelago of fragments” (Paz 26), we grow more and more interested in what is not said, the pauses and spaces and gaps, the traces and echoes, the detours and diversions.
Richard Miller declared: “This is my story. But it is not my story only” (176). Arresting Hope is an exemplar of transdisciplinary research. Patricia Leavy noted that transdisciplinarity provides a significant way for researchers “to seriously engage with the major issues and problems of our time” by pooling “our resources in the service of addressing complex contemporary problems” (8). Leavy defined transdisciplinarity as “an approach to conducting social research that involves synergistic collaboration between two or more disciplines with high levels of integration between the disciplinary sets of knowledge” (9). Arresting Hope involves many people who work across disciplinary boundaries, and who are learning from and listening to one another.
Walter Brueggemann claimed that “human transformative activity depends upon a transformed imagination” (xx). And imagination is integrally connected to language and recognizing “how singularly words, speech, language, and phrase shape consciousness and define reality” (64). Transformation, both personal and political, individual and cultural, depends on remembering and hoping. We need to grieve with compassion and empathy, question with critical energy, and examine creative possibilities with passion and hope. Brueggemann wrote, “the evocation of an alternative reality” involves the creation of “a new rhetoric” (18). Brueggemann called for more poetry, more stories, more imagination:
The prophet engages in futuring fantasy. The prophet does not ask if the vision can be implemented, for questions of implementation are of no consequence until the vision can be imagined. The imagination must come before the implementation. (40)
Arresting Hope is a testimony to what is possible when a community of people engage together in imagining alternative possibilities.
As Brueggemann recognized, “speech about hope cannot be explanatory and scientifically argumentative; rather, it must be lyrical in the sense that it touches the hopeless person at many different points” (65). In Arresting Hope, we present many voices and write in hopeful ways in order to sustain hearts with abiding hope. We agree with Gregory Orr who testified convincingly to “the survival function of story-making: it helps us to live” (21).
Like Miller, we pursue writing that fosters “a kind of critical optimism that is able to transform idle feelings of hope into viable plans for sustainable action” (27). Miller argued for the value of writing that extends beyond the boundaries of traditional academic discourse, and called for “writing as a place where the personal and the academic, the private and the public, the individual and the institutional, are always inextricably interwoven” (31). Miller invited us to write in diverse ways so each of us can “locate one’s evolving narrative within a specific range of institutional contexts, shifting attention from the self to the nexus where the self and institution meet” (138). This is the goal of the kind of life writing that shapes Arresting Hope. By writing about the past, we make sense of the past while also generating “a sense of possibility, a sense that a better, brighter future is out there to be secured” (Miller 20).
Arresting Hope reminds us that prisons are not only places of punishment, marginalization, and trauma, but that they can also be places of hope, blessing even, where people with difficult lived experiences can begin to compose stories full of healing, anticipation, communication, education, connection, and community. We are not presenting a romantic or nostalgic version of the story of the Alouette Correctional Centre for Women. We are presenting a story that acknowledges pressing challenges, but we are also eager to present a testimony to how hopefulness is possible in prison. We promote hope because we have been arrested by hope’s possibilities.
Arresting Hope is artistic, academic, and activist. With characteristic wisdom, JeanVanier asked:
Is this not the life undertaking of us all … to become human? It can be a long and sometimes painful process. It involves a growth to freedom, an opening up of our hearts to others, no longer hiding behind masks or behind the walls of fear and prejudice. It means discovering our common humanity. (1)
May we always be able to learn from and lean on one another.
Baldwin, Christina. Storycatcher: Making Sense of Our Lives through the Power and Practice of Story. Novato: New World Library, 2005.
Baudrillard, Jean. Fragments: Cool Memories iii, 1991-1995. Trans. Emily Agar. London: Verso, 1997.
Brueggemann, Walter. The Prophetic Imagination. 2nd ed. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2001.
Chatman, S. Story and Discourse: Narrative Structure in Fiction and Film. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1978.
Leavy, Patricia. Essentials of Transdisciplinary Research: Using Problem-Centered Methodologies. Walnut Creek, ca: Left Coast Press, 2011.
Leggo, Carl. “Narrative Inquiry: Attending to the Art of Discourse.” Language &Literacy 10 (1) (2008): 1-21.
Miller, Richard E. Writing at the End of the World. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 2005.
Orr, Gregory. Poetry as Survival. Athens: University of Georgia Press, 2002.
Palmer, Parker J. A Hidden Wholeness: The Journey Toward an Undivided Life. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2004.
Paz, Octavio. The Other Voice: Essays on Modern Poetry. Trans. Helen Lane. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1990.
Vanier, Jean. Becoming Human. Toronto: House of Anansi Press, 1998.